Tags
Agency Design
Branding
Content Strategy
Design
Functional design
Informational booklet
Marketing
Print Design
share on social

Make the Super Bowl Logo Great Again

The Tribe
Published
19 Dec 2016

In the world of consumer marketing, brand consistency is important – in marketing class, we’re told this fact over and over again. It’s marketing on a higher level – adding trust, reducing confusion, driving loyalty, reinforcing key messaging, and differentiating your brand from the competition.

There’s a reason why the world’s top businesses, like Apple and Google, place such a huge emphasis on getting it right – it’s important stuff.

Knowing all of this, it still doesn’t change my opinion that the NFL’s decision in 2010 to standardize the logo of their annual championship game, the Super Bowl, was the wrong move, announced by the NFL’s design firm, Landor, in 2010:

“The NFL has historically introduced a dramatically different Super Bowl logo every year based primarily on the location of the game, and using roman numerals for greatest impact. Landor’s strategy for the new visual identity system places at the heart of it the Vince Lombardi trophy, given to the Super Bowl’s winning team each year. Depending on the NFL event, the new system allows for complementary elements to be introduced. The released version, for the Arlington 2011 Super Bowl XLV, is the first example of a region-specific identity which will include each year’s stadium venue and the roman numerals to designate the event. This system affords the NFL consistency from year to year, regardless of the playoff event.”

Just like that, the magic was extinguished. Can you spot when the change was made?

screen-shot-2016-12-16-at-4-52-48-pm

Via: The Atlantic (City Lab), NFL.comNo longer did each logo’s colors, imagery, shape, typeface, and theme match the host city’s personality and the design trends of that time. No longer did each Super Bowl stand alone as a unique, stand alone event, completely unique and independent from other years' big games, like the Super Bowl logos of 1996, 2001, 2003, and 2005 (my personal favorites):New Orleans’ 1996 Super Bowl logo, paying homage to Mardi Gras.

sb36-300x250

Via: NFL.comThe 2001 Super Bowl logo, made to invoke a sense of patriotism and unity in the country after the attacks of 9/11.

super_bowl_xxxvi_logo-svg_-300x282

Via: NFL.comHouston’s 2003 Super Bowl logo, serving as a tribute to the city’s indelible connection to NASA and the Johnson Space Center:

super_bowl_xxxviii-svg_-300x269

Via: NFL.comDetroit's 2005 Super Bowl logo, a nod to the city’s rich automobile manufacturing history:

500px-super_bowl_xl-svg_-300x169

Via: NFL.comThese sort of colorful, imaginative, and completely unique logos were squashed for this template:

boringlogos

Via: SportsLogos.NetSure, the Super Bowl logo is now consistent and uniform, but to what end? The Super Bowl isn’t a brand that’s shown off to the public year around, where it would truly benefit from a consistent look. Rather it’s a one-time event, in the public’s consciousness for about a week each year. What’s the point in establishing brand consistency for something you’ll see once a year and probably forget about in a month?As marketers, we need to do a better job of ensuring creativity isn’t sacrificed in the name of branding consistency. It’s crucial we find that right balance of creativity while delivering on the needs of the business and end-user.

Contact Us

Let's build a tribe together

Ideas, Ideas, Ideas

DESIGN
July 2, 2025

The Role of Empathy in Modern Marketing

Attention spans are shrinking and algorithms shift faster than brand loyalty—what truly cuts through the noise in modern marketing isn’t just strategy. It’s empathy.

Learn More
DESIGN
June 27, 2025

TikTok Made Me Buy It: Why They Have The World's Most Addictive Ads

What makes TikTok ads so irresistible? Why do we go from scrolling to swiping our cards in seconds? And more importantly, what can marketers learn from that?Let’s break down why TikTok's ad strategy is the most addictive on the planet.

Learn More
DESIGN
June 25, 2025

The KPI Dilemma: Are Likes Leading You Astray?

It’s tempting to chase what’s visible. We all love a good screenshot of “likes blowing up” in the group chat. But growth doesn’t always look like applause. Sometimes, it looks like a quiet uptick in qualified leads. A steady climb in average order value. A new stream of referrals.

Learn More

Featured Work

We don’t just deliver - we make a difference.

Here’s a look at some of our most impactful branding, web, and campaign work. These aren’t just projects - they’re proof of what’s possible when bold ideas meet the right tribe.

See More
Drag to explore more